Sherlock Holmes Fans, You Need to Watch This Crime Drama… a Former Fake Psychic Who Can Read People Like Open Books, Outsmart Criminals With Just a Few Observations and Hunt Down the Serial Killer Who Destroyed His Family. With seven gripping seasons and a finale fans still can’t stop talking about, The Mentalist is being hailed as “one of the best crime dramas ever”.

“One of the Best Crime Dramas Ever”: The Mentalist Is a Must-Watch for Sherlock Holmes Fans – All Seven Seasons Are on Netflix

A brilliant mind, an uncanny ability to spot details others miss, and a personal vendetta that drives him to hunt down a ruthless killer. For fans of Sherlock Holmes-style mysteries, The Mentalist has all the ingredients of a gripping crime drama.

First arriving on television in September 2008, the series built a loyal following over seven seasons and 151 episodes. Created by Bruno Heller and led by Simon Baker and Robin Tunney, it carved out its own place in the police procedural genre with a mix of intricate investigations, sharp humour and a much larger mystery running beneath the weekly cases.

Still from The Mentalist

A detective who sees what everyone else misses

Baker stars as Patrick Jane, a former fake psychic who puts his unusual observational skills and deep understanding of human behaviour to work for the police.

The official synopsis sets out his central mission: after exposing himself as a fraud, Jane joins law enforcement in the hope of finding Red John, the killer responsible for murdering his family.

Robin Tunney co-stars alongside Baker, with Tim Kang, Owain Yeoman, Amanda Righetti, Rockmond Dunbar, Joe Adler and Josie Loren rounding out the cast.

The show’s premise has inevitably invited comparisons with other mystery favourites, including Sherlock Holmes and The X-Files. Baker’s performance was also recognised with a Primetime Emmy Award nomination for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series.

Still from The Mentalist 7, ep. 701 "Nothing But Blue Skies..."

Viewers praise its mysteries – and the ending

The series has earned a 90% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, with viewers highlighting its combination of suspense, humour, memorable characters and carefully constructed storylines.

One enthusiastic fan called it a personal favourite among police procedurals, praising its blend of “drama, action, comedy, suspense” and describing Baker as “absolutely perfect” in the role of Patrick Jane.

Another viewer made a direct comparison with Sherlock Holmes, pointing to Jane’s talent for spotting tiny details, reading people’s emotions and setting elaborate traps. They described him as a more troubled version of the legendary detective.

The show’s conclusion has also left a strong impression. One viewer called it “one of the best endings i could ever imagine”, while another praised the way its final episodes brought the story to a satisfying close.

That same fan revealed that their family had watched the entire series together three times, highlighting just how much they enjoyed its characters and long-running story arcs.

Still from The Mentalist

A crime drama with more than just weekly cases

The appeal of The Mentalist lies in how it balances standalone investigations with the continuing hunt for Red John. Episodes offer new crimes to solve while gradually moving Jane’s personal story forward.

Critics have praised that approach, with one describing the series as “funny, thoughtful and intricately plotted”. Another highlighted its ability to combine complicated cases with equally compelling characters.

For anyone looking for a crime drama that offers clever deductions, psychological games and a mystery stretching across multiple seasons, The Mentalist is well worth adding to the watchlist.

All seven seasons of the series are currently available to stream on Netflix.