The Heartbreaking True Story Behind Last Night’s ‘Marshals’ Episode
Mo Brings Plenty brought his real-life tragedy to prime time to raise awareness for MMIP.

The Sunday, November 15, episode of Marshals—Season 2, Episode 6, titled “Roughstock”—shined a spotlight on a harsh reality that Indigenous people face all too often. While the episode served as overarching commentary on tragedies against Indigenous people regularly being overlooked, it hits closer to home than might meet the eye. While Taylor Sheridan series are known for candidly highlighting systemic issues facing the modern world, the writers of “Roughstock” brought Mo Brings Plenty’s nightmare to prime time, giving the real-life storyline the attention it deserves.
During the 43-minute episode, Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) ventures outside his jurisdiction to help Mo (Mo Brings Plenty) track down his missing nephew. When they eventually found him dead, the police refused to investigate his death. In a heartbreaking twist, this storyline is a page out of Mo’s real life.
In April 2024, Mo’s nephew and fellow Yellowstone universe actor, Cole Brings Plenty (who played Pete Plenty Clouds in 1923), was found dead after being reported missing. The Lawrence Police Department in Kansas surmised that no foul play was involved and ruled his death a suicide, despite his family pushing for an investigation.
“For his murder to go uninvestigated, and for it to be written off as ‘no foul play,’ because they didn’t want to invest anything into it? It’s heartbreaking,” Mo told The Hollywood Reporter in March 2026. “We’re not letting it go.”
Given his reality, Mo, who is an enrolled member of the Lakota Nations, plays Thomas Rainwater’s (Gil Birmingham) right-hand man on Yellowstone and Marshals, and serves as the American Indian Affairs coordinator on Marshals, is grateful for the opportunity to share the injustices that face the Indigenous community with care.
“It all began when my brother, Joe, Cole’s father, and I were sharing the experience of what we were going through,” Mo told The Hollywood Reporter in an exclusive interview. “[Marshals showrunner] Spencer [Hudnut] mentioned something about it being up to us. Saying, ‘I know it’s gonna be deep, and it’s hard. But it’s up to you.’ We said, we have to do it. Not just for the sake of remembrance or in honoring Cole, but for all the other cases, all the other families whose cases of their loved ones not being looked at or being taken seriously and just thrown away. It was very important.”
The fact that Spencer put it on the table in the first place meant a lot to Mo and his family. “Mad respect for Spencer,” he told THR, commending him for taking the premise to the studio and network.
Mo also praised Spencer and the rest of the Marshals cast for how they handled the writing and brought the episode to life. “Spencer and the writing team are a great group of amazing, beautiful human beings,” he told THR. “My brother and I went to the writers’ room early on, before the season even started, to spend a day with them. We talked about different things that go on within tribal councils, the political side of what goes on on a reservation, the non-political side of it, and then, of course, we shared our experience of not talking about the MMIW (Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women) and MMIP (Missing and Murdered Indigenous People), but actually conveying what it’s really like to have that experience. There are hundreds and hundreds of families who have their loved ones… murdered and missing; the disappearance of loved ones just being written off as nothing.”
As tragic as this experience has been for Mo and his family, he felt called to share the story when given the platform, especially knowing that he had a group of people around him who he could count on to lift him up if reliving the tragedy on screen became too much.
“It was also good to have Luke Grimes there, and Gil Birmingham, and the crew; individuals who understood and knew,” Mo said, noting that he wanted to do his nephew justice, but knew it’d be difficult in the process. “Will [Strongheart], who portrayed [Mo’s onscreen nephew] Troy, was very familiar. He came to Cole’s funeral; they all knew what we were going through, especially for me. So it was easy to fall back into that space, because I knew there were others who would be there to help me if I needed it. But at the forefront of my mind was the injustice that occurs to American Indian people and the victims who are truly victims who are being labeled otherwise and not being taken seriously.”
“Roughstock,” along with Marshals Season 1 and the aired episodes of Season 2 are available to stream on Paramount+.